‘It was hard enough before’: Manitoba’s drought, worsened by climate crisis, is upending Prairie life
Farmers wait, desperate for rain, in a prolonged season of extremely dry conditions across central...
BC Hydro granted by far the largest Site C dam direct award contract to a construction company belonging to McLeod Lake Indian Band, the Treaty 8 member that has spoken out widely in support of the project, according to documents The Narwhal obtained through a Freedom of Information (FOI) request.
Duz Cho Construction, a Chetwynd-based company with roots in the oil patch and mining industry, received a $29.5 million direct contract for “site preparation” work in 2016 on the Peace River’s south bank, according to the documents.
The contract was among 38 Site C project direct award contracts worth close to $90 million that BC Hydro granted from March 2016 to October 2018, including contracts to numbered companies, the documents show.
Direct award contracts allow BC Hydro and other public bodies to decide which companies or consultants get contracts, instead of going through a more transparent and competitive tender process.
Four companies that donated to the BC Liberal Party were awarded contracts totalling $11.5 million, while an oil and gas corporation that owns an inactive gas well in the Site C dam construction zone was awarded almost $1 million from BC Hydro to permanently cap the well.
Dermod Travis, executive director of Integrity BC, a non-partisan organization working to ensure integrity and accountability, pointed to Thursday’s far-reaching Supreme Court of Canada Redwater decision that energy companies — and not governments or regulators — must pay to clean up their abandoned wells.
“When it comes to abandoned wells the people who should pay for the clean-up and make sure it’s safe and secure are the people who made the wells in the first place and we shouldn’t be paying to clean up their mess,” Travis said in an interview.
The names of an additional 10 direct award recipients were redacted from the FOI response on the grounds that disclosure would be harmful to the financial or economic interests of BC Hydro or the B.C. government. (The Narwhal has requested that the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner review BC Hydro’s decision to keep those 10 recipients and the amount of public money they received secret.)
Travis said no government body should be able to withhold the names of companies receiving public money.
BC Hydro is already obliged to disclose an annual list of every contract it awards, Travis pointed out, although that list is not broken down by project.
“I don’t know what they’re trying to gain by this except continue to make themselves look like this secret club.”
Travis also said he was troubled by five contracts, worth a total of $15.8 million, that BC Hydro awarded directly to three different numbered companies either for “river road remediation and sediment control” or for the Site C shuttle service.
The shuttle meets workers that BC Hydro flies in and out of the Fort St. John airport on chartered planes or commercial flights and provides “Site C leisure” buses to transport workers to activities.
Numbered companies receiving public money should have their ownership clearly identified, Travis said, noting that transparency is especially important in light of the unfolding expenditure scandal at the B.C. Legislature.
“You have no idea who it is, who owns the company. The idea of hiding behind a numbered company automatically causes the public to believe there’s something fishy. A government, particularly in today’s day and age, needs to go out of its way to avoid the public thinking that something is fishy.”
The information about Site C project direct award contracts was released to The Narwhal as BC Hydro goes to court seeking to overturn an order from B.C. Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner that compels the public utility to release the names of employees who adjudicate lucrative Site C project procurement proposals.
The list of direct award contracts released in the FOI response includes:
Travis said most of the direct award contracts should have gone out to tender.
The New West Partnership Trade Agreement among Canada’s western provinces mandates that any services or construction contract greater than $100,000 should be issued through open tender unless a public agency can prove an urgent or specialized need.
BC Hydro’s FOI response was titled, “Direct Award Allowed under New West Partnership Agreement.”
But Travis said BC Hydro “has an obligation” to explain how each of those direct award contracts meet conditions set out in the partnership trade agreement.
“I cannot understand why BC Hydro would not put it to tender so that all the companies potentially eligible to bid would bid and BC Hydro would be able to choose the best value for the contract awards. Without knowing what their potential justification for it is, it obviously raises red flags, particularly given the state of the project at this point.”
The price tag for Site C — announced as a $6.6 billion project in 2010 — soared to $10.7 billion at the end of 2017, just two years into the nine-year construction project.
“The idea that you’re now direct awarding contracts and not going out and trying to get the best price is somewhat of an insult to the people who are going to have to pick up the bill,” Travis said.
“The province has been for too many years a closed shop when it comes to infrastructure projects. And when you have a closed shop you have higher prices.”
Other Treaty 8 First Nations also figure prominently in the direct award contracts.
BC Hydro granted contracts to companies connected to three other B.C. Treaty 8 First Nations that have signed Site C impact and benefits agreements with the public utility.
Those nations have not spoken out publicly in favour of the Site C dam, which will flood their traditional territory, eliminate prime hunting and trapping grounds, and contaminate bull trout and other fish in the Peace River and its tributaries with methylmercury.
Halfway River International was awarded a $13.3 million contract as a “Site C Health Clinic Provider,” while Halfway River IDL Ltd. Partnership received $3.5 million for a grading and paving contract. Both companies are part of the Halfway River group.
Doig River Timber Ltd. received $357,000 for “north bank grinding.” Paul Paquette & Sons Contracting, a company owned by Saulteau First Nations members, was awarded one contract for $1.9 million and another for $897,206 for “clearing” work on both banks of the Peace River.
Blueberry River First Nation, whose treaty rights legal case is on hold pending negotiations with the B.C. government, was awarded a $496,000 contract for “Site C Wildlife Mitigation Structures Construction.”
The Twin Sisters Native Plants Nursery, run by the Saulteau First Nations and West Moberly First Nations, was awarded $618,000 for seed supply and delivery.
West Moberly First Nations and Prophet River First Nation have filed civil actions claiming that Site C, along with two other dams on the Peace River, unjustifiably infringes on their constitutionally protected treaty rights.
The question of whether the Site C dam violates treaty rights has never been tested in the courts.
The list of direct award contracts in the FOI response include another $12.1 million that BC Hydro paid to other arms of the B.C. government for Site C permits and to meet other requirements, as well as money it paid to municipalities negatively affected by the project.
An e-mailed statement from B.C.’s energy ministry said the Site C project’s “cost-to-complete” remained at $10.7 billion as of January 2019.
The statement came after BC Hydro’s latest quarterly Site C “progress report” to the B.C. Utilities Commission listed seven out of 12 areas pertaining to the project’s status as cause for “some concerns but in control,” including the project’s overall health, its schedule and cost.
The energy ministry e-mail also said that the government has not yet determined if the B.C. public will be privy to reporting from the Site C Project Assurance Board, established by the NDP government in January 2018 to ensure the project stays on time and within its revised budget.
“Until that decision is made, minutes and reports of the board remain confidential,” the ministry told The Narwhal.
Last year, an international hydro dam construction expert described the high level of confidentiality surrounding the Site C project as “extraordinary” and said he has never encountered such secrecy during his five decades designing, developing and managing large hydroelectric projects, including in China.
And since you’re here, we have a favour to ask. Our independent, ad-free journalism is made possible because the people who value our work also support it (did we mention our stories are free for all to read, not just those who can afford to pay?).
As a non-profit, reader-funded news organization, our goal isn’t to sell advertising or to please corporate bigwigs — it’s to bring evidence-based news and analysis to the surface for all Canadians. And at a time when most news organizations have been laying off reporters, we’ve hired five journalists over the past year.
Not only are we filling a void in environment coverage, but we’re also telling stories differently — by centring Indigenous voices, by building community and by doing it all as a people-powered, non-profit outlet supported by more than 3,300 members.
The truth is we wouldn’t be here without you. Every single one of you who reads and shares our articles is a crucial part of building a new model for Canadian journalism that puts people before profit.
We know that these days the world’s problems can feel a *touch* overwhelming. It’s easy to feel like what we do doesn’t make any difference, but becoming a member of The Narwhal is one small way you truly can make a difference.
We’ve drafted a plan to make 2021 our biggest year yet, but we need your support to make it all happen.
If you believe news organizations should report to their readers, not advertisers or shareholders, please become a monthly member of The Narwhal today for any amount you can afford.
Everything in an ecosystem is connected. A tiny sapling relies on a towering ancient tree, just like a newborn baby depends on its mother. And...Continue reading
Farmers wait, desperate for rain, in a prolonged season of extremely dry conditions across central...
Ocean waters are now warmer, more acidic and hold less oxygen. They’re also stressed from...
Ahead of a likely federal election, the Liberals committed to covering the vast majority of...
We’re on the verge of launching an Ontario bureau. Stay in the know by signing up for a weekly dose of our ad‑free, independent journalism.