This is an excerpt from Temperature Check, a weekly newsletter about what’s hot, and what’s not, when it comes to energy and the environment in Canada. Subscribe now to receive next week’s edition in your inbox.


On Sunday, Telus pulled out of plans to build two AI data centres in Vancouver. That adds to a year of opposition, rejections and moratoriums across the country. One look at the wildly different takes on what big wins by anti-data-centre politicians in the U.S. midterms mean for Canada shows the gulf between believers and skeptics here isn’t shrinking.

Skeptics’ long list of concerns include significant greenhouse gases and intense use of energy and water. Believers — including the Alberta, Ontario and federal governments — argue only Canadian data centres can protect our sensitive information. Any chance of finding a middle ground requires proof they’re truly working to lock our data down.

That proof has yet to materialize. The non-partisan think tank Canadian Shield Institute has criticized big federal data investments it says don’t actually keep our info safe at home, including a military deal with the controversial tech firm Palantir. The institute doles out “sovereignty scores” for federal commitments … and gave a weak 2 out of 10 to a $240-million investment in the Canadian AI company Cohere in 2024.

It found Cohere’s plan to buy processing power from a facility located in Canada, but owned by an American company, allows U.S. authorities to demand access to the data. All that public money, the institute’s analysis says, would do “little to build Canadian-owned digital infrastructure, reduce dependence on foreign firms … or guarantee that long-term AI capacity remains under Canadian control.”

Yet the feds just octupled their investment into Cohere by pledging a staggering $1.6 billion. Institute board member Jim Balsillie — an undeniable advocate for Canadian tech — told CBC the move “doesn’t hold up to scrutiny for a public investment.”

This doesn’t sound like the independence strategy Canadians are being promised. It also isn’t a persuasive argument that investing in supercomputing is a better sovereignty bet than conserving the environmental resources those plans put at risk.


For more Temperature Check, subscribe to The Narwhal’s newsletters.