What would a Pierre Poilievre government mean for Manitoba’s environment?
Here’s a how a provincial NDP government and the federal Conservative leader align — and...
Get the inside scoop on The Narwhal’s environment and climate reporting by signing up for our free newsletter.
All three parties that now hold seats in the B.C. legislature promised major changes to the use of glyphosate in forestry operations during the recent provincial election campaign.
The BC Greens promised to ban the use of all chemical herbicides, including glyphosate, in forestry. The BC Conservatives committed to stop all aerial spraying of glyphosate. And the BC NDP, returned to government in a slim majority, promised to phase out the industry’s use of the controversial herbicide.
Ecologists and advocates welcomed the commitment, but they warn it’s not just glyphosate that needs to go — it’s the broader policies that prioritize timber over diverse ecosystems.
Those policies have resulted in more than one million hectares of forest in B.C. sprayed with herbicides since the 1970s to kill off plants and trees — from berries and wildflowers to groves of fire-resistant aspen — that industry and government view as unwanted competition for conifer plantations. Those same species have been manually cut back from another 1.5 million hectares across the province, according to data analyzed for The Narwhal by Nikita Wallia, a spatial analyst and cartography specialist.
While glyphosate use has declined significantly in recent years, the impacts of past spraying are still visible in forests today.
B.C. government data shows herbicides have been sprayed across more than one million hectares of forest since the 1970s. Ground applications are displayed in yellow and aerial spraying is displayed in blue on the map. Companies have also manually cut back aspen, berries and other plants across roughly 1.5 million hectares of the province, displayed in red. Map: Nikita Wallia / The Narwhal
The Narwhal reviewed more than 2,000 pages of herbicide reports forestry companies submitted to the B.C. government in response to a freedom of information request. Those reports show companies target a host of species with herbicide treatments, from aspen and cottonwood to willows and rose.
Many of the targeted plants provide food not just for deer, moose, bears and birds but also for people, who harvest berries and medicinal plants from the land. Mixed forests, made up of diverse species, have been found to be more resistant to pests and disease. Aspen, maples, poplars and other deciduous trees return nutrients to the soil when their leaves fall each autumn.
Aspens play an important role wherever they’re found. Beavers prefer aspen trunks and twigs to build their dams. Birds nest in their cavities. Moose, deer and black bears eat their leaves. And, during the height of wildfire seasons, groves of relatively moist aspens can serve as a natural fire break. But those benefits are eroded or lost entirely when aspen are culled from forests where timber production is prioritized.
A spokesperson for the provincial Forests Ministry reiterated the government’s commitment to phase out the use of glyphosate and said the ministry is considering amending the policies that prioritize timber over other ecological values.
Updated Dec. 20, 2024, at 12 p.m. PT: The map caption in this article was updated to include details from the map’s colour-coded legend.
Get the inside scoop on The Narwhal’s environment and climate reporting by signing up for our free newsletter. For a moment in the glow of a...
Continue readingHere’s a how a provincial NDP government and the federal Conservative leader align — and...
More than a decade into environmental journalism, my message remains the same: we’ve got way...
An international network of scientists, educators and organizations is teaming up to track bird migration,...