Who’s going to end up footing the cleanup bill for Alberta’s oilsands?

The province has less than $1 billion in guaranteed cash on hand, with experts arguing that oil companies ‘backended all of their liabilities’

This is the web version of The Narwhal’s newsletter. Go here to sign up.

On April 17, with the energy industry in crisis, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced $1.7 billion in federal funding for cleaning up a long-festering environmental liability: orphan and inactive oil and gas wells.

While it was viewed as a positive step to fix a growing problem, it also drew criticism for offloading the responsibilities of private corporations onto taxpayers. And it got us thinking about the fate of an even more expensive cleanup obligation: Alberta’s oilsands.

The Alberta Energy Regulator says publicly that the liabilities of open-pit mining — the operations that produce tailings ponds — amount to $30 billion, though its internal estimates calculated a “worst-case scenario” of $130 billion in costs.

So, how much guaranteed cleanup cash does the province have on hand as the industry grapples with a declining market? A grand total of less than $1 billion.

Industry has “backended all of their liabilities,” University of Calgary professor Martin Olszynski tells The Narwhal’s Sharon J. Riley.

And it’s not simply a matter of money: experts say current technologies for remediating tailings ponds are “unproven,” with scant proof of whether healthy landscapes can be built on top of the waste water and toxic residue.

Here’s where that leaves us: a swath of land nearly twice the size of Vancouver that will need remediation, with no more than three per cent of necessary funds guaranteed, no surefire solution to successfully clean it all up and an industry grappling with record-low prices and mounting climate concerns.

Who’s going to end up footing the bill?

Read more about the elephant in the room and keep scrolling for much more this week.

Arik Ligeti
Audience Engagement Editor

P.S. We rely on support from dedicated readers like you to help us produce in-depth, one-of-a-kind coverage of the oilsands. If you’re able, please join The Narwhal family by becoming a monthly member today.

This week in The Narwhal

Ottawa is paying to clean up Alberta’s inactive wells. Are the oilsands next?

Oilsands reclamation site

By Sharon J. Riley

As $1 billion in federal funds go to clean up inactive wells, experts are sounding alarm bells about the ‘super experimental’ realm of tailings ponds reclamation and what could be more than $100 billion in unfunded liabilities in the oilsands. Read more.  

B.C. opens Sunshine Coast forest — home to some of Canada’s oldest trees — to logging

Ancient yellow cedar Dakota Ridge Elphinstone Logging Focus

By Judith Lavoie

Local conservation group asks province to cancel cutblocks containing ancient yellow cedars and unofficial bear sanctuary. Read more

Lake Ontario ‘aquatic landfill’ to contain 150-year-old toxic blob from industrial pollution

Steel mill Hamilton Ontario

By Kelly Bennett

A $139-million underwater box the size of six city blocks is being built to contain an underwater contaminated zone in Hamilton’s Randle Reef for some 200 years. While critics point out the answer to the steel town’s historic pollution shouldn’t be found in making more steel, others say the technique should be considered for other toxic sites in Canadian waters. Read more.  

Canada’s conservation efforts must prioritize areas resilient to climate change, researchers say

Conservation planning climate change impacts

By Ainslie Cruickshank

New studies show factoring climate change impacts into planning for protected areas can help achieve emission-reduction and biodiversity targets — a move one scientist calls ‘hitting the conservation science jackpot.’ Read more.

‘A contaminated mess’: how a Yukon mine left behind a $35-million clean-up bill

Wolverine mine reclamation

By Julien Gignac

The territorial government is on the hook to clean up the Wolverine mine after its owner went bankrupt. A system in place to secure funds for remediation throughout a mine’s life should have prevented this scenario, but it didn’t — and that doesn’t bode well for future mine clean-ups. Read more.

What we’re reading

The Narwhal in the world

How do you report on the COVID-19 pandemic in Indigenous contexts? That was the subject of an eye-opening University of British Columbia online panel discussion featuring Narwhal reporter Stephanie Wood and board member Candis Callison. 

“Ive seen a lot of people talking about racism as a pandemic and climate change as the biggest emergency that were facing,” Stephanie said, adding that Canadian media should “cover those things with the same urgency that we cover COVID.”

Stephanie also talked about her reporting on a B.C. First Nation that was flooded with project referrals amid the pandemic as well as how Indigenous communities are balancing food security and conservation.

Go here to watch the webinar.

Note from a Narwhal

Niall, a new monthly member, nearly brought us to tears with this beautiful note: “I absolutely love the work that you are all doing. It can be heart-breaking to read your articles, but it is so important to shed light on what is happening between humans and nature. I am so happy to give my money to a well-deserving organization.”

Help us shed more light on the relationship between people and the natural world by becoming a monthly member of The Narwhal today.

When a long day has you exhausted. Tell your friends to sign up for our newsletter before they get some shut-eye.

Parks Canada warns of ‘irreversible harm’ if Ontario proceeds with Greenbelt development

Parks Canada says Ontario would be violating an agreement between the federal and provincial governments if it goes ahead with plans to open up parts...

Continue reading

Recent Posts

The Narwhal is only possible because a tiny fraction of readers like you donate whatever they can to keep our journalism free for all to read.
Help keep our journalism free for all to read.
Get The Narwhal in your inbox!
People always tell us they love our newsletter. Find out yourself with a weekly dose of our ad‑free, independent journalism
Get The Narwhal in your inbox!
People always tell us they love our newsletter. Find out yourself with a weekly dose of our ad‑free, independent journalism