Photographer Ryan Wilkes’ vibrant photos of soon-to-be renamed warblers and hummingbirds are evidence of how old and pervasive that racism is. They illustrate Ontario reporter Emma McIntosh’s conversations with Black birdwatchers about the American Ornithological Society’s decision to rename birds named after people, some of whom were enslavers, colonizers or white supremacists.
Many of the birders Emma spoke with have felt dismissed and occasionally unsafe while simply trying to enjoy the natural world. Their experiences ring true because unfortunately, The Narwhal received some negative feedback about the stories we published this Black History Month. One person was angry we published Emma’s story at all, saying (among other, less printable things) it was outside of our core mandate to report on the environment.
I strongly disagree. Nature is for everyone, and dismantling the many barriers to accessing it is a climate imperative. As misinformation spreads like wildfire, preserving biodiversity doesn’t only mean sharing space — it means actually ceding space to people whose knowledge is often more useful than the types of “expertise” Western systems value. Genuinely working together to stave off the most urgent crisis of our time requires humility, and listening.
Besides, “something that flies freely like a bird in the sky,” as birder Shontal Cargill put it to Emma, shouldn’t bear “this legacy through no fault of its own.” That legacy is humanity’s to carry, and to repair. As we work to protect the planet we all love and live on, let’s do a better job of protecting each other, too.
Take care and dream big,
Denise Balkissoon
Ontario bureau chief
|