This is an excerpt from The Narwhal This Week, a behind-the-scenes look at our reporting on the natural world in Canada. Subscribe to get it in your inbox.


“A mockery of British Columbia’s constitutional duties.”

That’s what Chief Keith Crow called B.C.’s approval of mineral staking claims in the nʔaysnúlaʔxʷ Indigenous Protected and Conserved Area (IPCA). The claims were approved after the Lower Similkameen Indian Band proposed the protected area in 2022. Those approvals, covering nearly a quarter of the proposed protected area, occurred without any consultation with band leadership, according to a press release by the band.

The release caught freelance reporter Cameron Fenton’s eye. He started digging into just how many approved claims exist inside protected areas, teaming up with data scientist Kira Lamont to map it all out. His investigation shows the true scale: over the past seven years, the outgoing BC NDP government approved 1,618 mineral tenures, covering 594,987 hectares, within proposed and declared IPCAs.

That’s … complicated, given the previous NDP government’s support for Indigenous-led conservation; the Lower Similkameen Indian Band got more than a million dollars for its protected area in 2023. The approval of claims in nʔaysnúlaʔxʷ, as well as other IPCAs across B.C., has created a big problem — and there’s one law undergirding it all.

Under B.C.’s Mineral Tenure Act, anyone can stake a mineral claim at just $1.75 per hectare. But if it’s in an area that becomes a park or protected area — and the claims are rendered unusable — the claim holder must be compensated to the tune of $250 and $850 per hectare. For these 1,600-plus claims? That payout could amount to $500 million — and it’s not clear who would foot the bill.

The province’s political shake-up, with the incoming BC Conservative government, has caused concerns for the future of IPCAs, like the three-million-hectare Dene Kʼéh Kusān in Kaska territory that was close to being finalized before the election was called. “The groundwork is done and the public is behind it,” Liard First Nation Chief Harlan Schilling told The Narwhal. “We hope the new government will see the value of that work and help us complete it.” How the new government approaches it all remains to be seen — although premier-elect Lorne Doerksen has emphasized his intent to ramp up mineral exploration.

But the extent of the problem, as Cameron’s investigation reveals, makes one thing painfully clear: this conflict won’t be resolved anytime soon.